A Dutch court ordered prosecutors to open an investigation on April 20 into whether a Royal Dutch Shell-ExxonMobil joint venture bears any criminal responsibility for earthquakes triggered by production at the country’s largest gas field.
No physical injuries have been caused by numerous small quakes, which have damaged thousands of buildings and structures across the northeastern province of Groningen, and prosecutors had previously declined to act, arguing it was a civil matter.
However, the Leeuwaarden-Arnhem Appeals Court directed them to open an investigation, saying they had not looked carefully enough at whether a crime could be proved.
The government was formally censured by the country’s Safety Board after a magnitude 3.6 quake hit the town of Huizinge in 2012. This was larger than had been deemed possible by NAM, the Royal Dutch Shell and ExxonMobil joint venture that oversees production at Groningen.
“The court observes that there is evidence that the NAM is culpable of...damaging buildings with threat to human life,” the court said in the April 20 ruling.
NAM, which has accepted civil responsibility for damage caused by the quakes and is paying damages of more than 1 billion euros (US$1.1 billion), said in a statement it was surprised by the decision over Groningen, which was discovered in 1959 and is one of the world's largest gas fields.
“In earlier rulings, prosecutors and the court have continually found that there was no reason for prosecution,” it said, adding that investigations do not automatically lead to charges being brought.
NAM spokesman Hein Dek declined any further comment.
Earlier this week, the Dutch government said it will again cut output at the field to lessen the risk posed by quakes. It is the fourth such move since the Safety Board’s pivotal February 2015 report said authorities had ignored potential risks at Groningen for decades and were putting lives in danger.
Output at Groningen has been steeply reduced from 53.9 Bcm (1.9 Tcf) in 2013 to a maximum of 24 Bcm (848 Bcf) on an annual basis at present; in October that will be further cut to 21.6 Bcm (763 Bcf).
Recommended Reading
EQT Ups Stake in Appalachia Gas Gathering Assets for $205MM
2024-02-14 - EQT Corp. inked upstream and midstream M&A in the fourth quarter—and the Appalachia gas giant is looking to ink more deals this year.
EQT Deal to ‘Vertically Integrate’ Equitrans Faces Steep Challenges
2024-03-11 - EQT Corp. plans to acquire Equitrans Midstream with $5.5 billion equity, but will assume debt of $7.6 billion or more in the process, while likely facing intense regulatory scrutiny.
Ohio Oil, Appalachia Gas Plays Ripe for Consolidation
2024-04-09 - With buyers “starved” for top-tier natural gas assets, Appalachia could become a dealmaking hotspot in the coming years. Operators, analysts and investors are also closely watching what comes out of the ground in the Ohio Utica oil fairway.
ONEOK CEO: ‘Huge Competitive Advantage’ to Upping Permian NGL Capacity
2024-03-27 - ONEOK is getting deeper into refined products and adding new crude pipelines through an $18.8 billion acquisition of Magellan Midstream. But the Tulsa company aims to capitalize on NGL output growth with expansion projects in the Permian and Rockies.
Chesapeake-Southwestern Deal Delayed Amid Feds Scrutiny of E&P M&A
2024-04-05 - The Federal Trade Commission asked Chesapeake and Southwestern for more information about their $7.4 billion merger — triggering an automatic 30-day waiting period as the agency intensifies scrutiny of E&P deals.